Track 7. Following a Process: exercise sheet
For engineers, students and instructors. One practice task and a few questions per chapter, to work through after each video. Print this page from your browser, or work on screen. The answer key starts on a new page at the end.
Before you start
7.1 Choosing a Process Guide
Watch chapter 7.1 (3:08)
Practice
On the CubeSat EO-1 demo project:
- Open your EO-1 demo project (if you have none, create it: Manage Projects → Project Files ▾ → New Demo Project → CubeSat (Guided systems engineering)). In the rail, open Plan → SE Process.
- Select Vee model and then DoD acquisition life cycle in the list, and read each one's summary and sources.
- Select ISO/IEC/IEEE 15288 and click Use This Process.
- Read the Concept stage: the technical process cards, then the technical management processes after them, and note which checks EO-1 already meets.
- In Process, switch to Vee model, look at its first phase, then switch back to ISO/IEC/IEEE 15288.
You're done when the SE Process page shows ISO/IEC/IEEE 15288 with its Concept stage marked Current.
Questions
- Does turning on a process guide change the model?
- You switch from one guide to another and back. What happens to your ticks and gates?
- How do you choose between the guides?
7.2 Live Checks and the Work They Point To
Watch chapter 7.2 (2:21)
Practice
On the CubeSat EO-1 demo project:
- Open your EO-1 demo project (if you have none, create it: Manage Projects → Project Files ▾ → New Demo Project → CubeSat (Guided systems engineering)). Open Plan → SE Process and choose Kossiakoff SE method (in Process, or select it and click Use This Process).
- In Needs analysis, read which checks are done and what their details count, for example the needs N1–N3.
- Next to the Needs Analysis document check, click Open. Click + New Document, enter
EO-1 Needs Analysis, choose Needs Analysis Document under Templates for, pick the template card, and click Create. - Return to SE Process and check that the document check is done and the phase's percentage went up.
- Tick the manual check about surveying existing systems and technologies, read who ticked it and when, then press ⌘Z / Ctrl+Z and tick it again.
You're done when the Needs Analysis document check is done and the survey check shows your name and the time.
Questions
- What is the difference between a check with a mark and a check with a checkbox?
- EO-1 records its needs as Statements. Why do they count as needs, while its section headings do not?
- Where does Open take you?
7.3 Phases and Gates
Watch chapter 7.3 (1:52)
Practice
On the CubeSat EO-1 demo project:
- Open your EO-1 demo project (if you have none, create it: Manage Projects → Project Files ▾ → New Demo Project → CubeSat (Guided systems engineering)). Open Plan → SE Process with Kossiakoff SE method, on the Needs analysis phase.
- At the bottom, under Phase gate, click Add Gate Milestone. Open the milestone and set its date two weeks from today.
- Click Create Review Package, open the package, and add the EO-1 System Requirements Specification to it.
- Click Concept exploration in the life cycle and read its checks: requirements, needs traced, quality checked and the trade study.
- Click Make Current Phase.
You're done when Concept exploration is marked Current and the needs analysis gate links to its milestone and review package.
Questions
- You wrote a new document after creating the review package. Is it in the package?
- What is the difference between clicking a phase and Make Current Phase?
- Where does the gate milestone show up?
7.4 Running a Technical Review from the Model
Watch chapter 7.4 (2:38)
Practice
On the CubeSat EO-1 demo project:
- Open your EO-1 demo project (if you have none, create it: Manage Projects → Project Files ▾ → New Demo Project → CubeSat (Guided systems engineering)). Open Plan → SE Process and choose NASA project life cycle in Process (or select it and click Use This Process).
- Click Phase B: Preliminary design and technology completion and read the PDR's entry criteria: allocation to components, interfaces, TPMs, mitigations and verification methods.
- Click Open next to a criterion that is not met and do one piece of the work, for example set the Verification Method of 2.5 Safe Mode Recovery.
- Return to SE Process and check the criterion's count.
- Under the PDR, click Add Gate Milestone and Create Review Package, and open the package to see which documents it collected.
You're done when the PDR shows its milestone and review package, and the criterion you worked on counts one more item.
Questions
- All of a review's entry criteria are met. Is the design ready?
- Why read entry criteria before the review rather than at it?
- The SRR criterion for tracing expectations to requirements is still open. What does it ask for?
Answer key
7.1 Choosing a Process Guide
- No. The guide reads the model and shows what each phase still needs. The choice of process is saved with the project and shared with its members, and ⌘Z / Ctrl+Z undoes it.
- Each process keeps its own current phase, ticked checks and gates, so switching back returns you to where you were.
- Pick the one your program or course follows: each guide's structure follows the sources named under it, such as NPR 7123.1 for the NASA life cycle. The descriptions and checks are Holarch's own.
7.2 Live Checks and the Work They Point To
- A mark (✓, ◐ or ○) is read from the model and changes as the model changes. A checkbox is for a judgment the model cannot show, such as feasibility; ticking it records who and when.
- The needs checks count Statements traced to requirements. A section Statement in a document counts as a need only once it is traced. Needs recorded as Requirements do not count as needs.
- To the page where the work for that check happens, such as Documents, Quality, the Traceability Matrix or Functional Analysis. Come back to SE Process to see the check update.
7.3 Phases and Gates
- No. The package includes the documents that exist when it is created. Add later documents to the package yourself.
- Clicking a phase only shows its checks. Make Current Phase changes where the project is, for everyone working on it.
- It is a Time item labeled Milestone. Once it has a date, it shows on the Project Management calendar and under Upcoming Events.
7.4 Running a Technical Review from the Model
- Not necessarily. The guide shows what the model holds; whether the design is good is the review board's decision.
- Holarch reads them from the model, so the team sees what is missing while there is still time to do the work.
- Links from the needs (Statements) to the requirements that answer them, made with traced to. It is modeling work, not a box to tick.
Published by Holarch